Miss Mustard Seed Milk Paint | Reinvented Furniture and Home Decor

The Easiest Upcycled Wooden Tray Makeover

Are you looking for the easiest upcycled wooden tray makeover that has actually has a purpose? Today, I am sharing the cutest wooden tray makeover ever!

Reinvented Delaware is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.  Amazon offers a small commission on products sold through its affiliate links.  Each of your purchases via our Amazon affiliation links supports this blog at no additional cost to you.  Again, the price of these items is exactly the same for you whether you purchase them through an affiliate link or a non-affiliate link

before and after Pinterest graphic showing upcycled wooden tray makeover

thrifted wooden tray

You’ve probably seen trays like this at thrift stores. They have slanted sides and are made from thin wood. Sometimes you can find them with country-style paintings or decals with daisies or some other country motif.

We seem to come across them often.

We also come across pillar candle stands like the green one you see here.

thrifted wood tray glued to green pillar candle stand

supplies for wooden tray makeover

Let’s take a look at how to turn these two unrelated and out-of-style home decor pieces into something useful and current with today’s style.

Here are the supplies you will need for this easy upcycled wooden tray makeover:

  • thrifted wooden tray (mine is about 9″ square and 2-3″ deep)
  • thrifted pillar candle stand (mine is about 5″ tall)
  • E6000 Glue
  • Zinserr Shellac Based Primer
  • sanding block
  • Zibra Square Paintbrush
  • Miss Mustard Seed Milk Paint (I used Ironstone)
  • Miss Mustard Seed Hemp Oil
  • blue shop towels
  • micro-fiber cloth
wood tray glued to green candle stand with supplies in foreground including Bin Shellac Primer, E6000 glue, Zibra Paintbrush, Miss Mustard Seed Bonding Agent, snading bock

what to do with an old wooden tray

Start by gluing the thrifted tray to the thrifted pillar candle stand with E6000 Glue. E6000 glue sticks anything to anything and it is a staple in my workshop.

Try your best to center the candle stand with the tray. You can measure if you like, I just eyeballed it 🙂

Place something heavy on top of the tray and let it dry overnight.

The next day, use the sanding block to scuff sand the surface just enough to rough it up a little bit. This will only take a minute, you don’t need to completely remove the finish on either section.

Afterwards, wipe it down with a damp micro-fiber cloth.

lady scuff sanding wood tray and pillar candle stand in preparation for upcycled wooden tray makeover

priming is optional

The next step is to prime the base. But let me mention, this is optional.

The thrifted pillar candle stand that I have is hard plastic and painted in a yucky green. I wanted to be sure the green wouldn’t show through the final paint color. Priming was the best way to prevent this

You can also prime the upcycled wooden tray for this makeover. I wanted the chippy finish to show some of the wood so I did not prime it.

Zinsser Bin Shellac Based Primer is my go to primer. It sticks to anything and anything sticks to it!

base of upcycled wooden tray makeover primed with Bin Shellac based primer in white

painting video

My friend Anna from Skylark House did an Instagram Live for this project. We have a lively discussion each month about our love of all things vintage!

Be sure to pop over to her site – she has some amazing vintage finds!

lady with her arm leaning on upcycled wooden tray makeover before the tray was painted with supplies and tripod ready for an Instagram Live Demo

You can click below to see our live chat about this easy wooden tray makeover. We’ll be chatting about using Miss Mustard Seed Milk Paint among other aspects of this project!

upcyled wooden tray makeover after the first coat of Miss Mustard Seed Milk Paint has been applied

how to refurbish a wooden tray

The upcycled wooden tray needed two and a half coats of paint. I say 2 1/2 coats because the last coat was more of a touch-up coat.

Milk paint dries to a chalky feeling finish so I used my worn-out sanding sponge to smooth the texture just a bit. Some of the paint chipped off giving it an antique look.

To seal the upcycled wooden tray, I used Miss Mustard Seek Hemp Oil. Wipe it on and wipe it off. It soaked into the wood and once it has cured for a couple of weeks, you can safely use this pedestal tray to hold fruit.

lady applying Miss Mustard Seed Hemp Oil to upcycled wooden tray makeover

how to use an upcycled wooden tray

Doesn’t it look so cute holding apples and bananas? We have made several of these pedestal-tray-thingies and our customers have loved them!

I have mine sitting on our dining room buffet near a botanical style fruit print.

dining room buffet with upcycled wooden tray, ironstone pitchers, stack of books and wall art

Let’s think of some other uses for this upcycled wooden tray!

Imagine with me, Ok?

upcycled wooden tray after makeover staged on buffet with fresh apples and ripe bananas and other home decor items

Maybe it could be used as a candle holder. Put a jarred candle in the center and add some greenery around the candle.

upcycled wooden tray makeover staged on top of buffet with fresh fruit inside tray and ironstone pitchers on the side

Fill empty mason jars with candies like M&M’s (my faves are peanut M&M”s!), individually wrapped Twizzlers, and bite-size chocolates like Dove Chocolates!

top view of upcycled wooden tray staged with apples and bananas in tray and two ironstone pitchers on the side

Ok, so I definitely have snack foods on my mind! Let’s say that this wooden tray would be perfect to serve homemade cookies!

Can’t you see a stack of chocolate chip cookies in this wooden tray?

Or maybe peanut butter cookies, sugar cookies???

O golly, I need to stop!

close up of chippy finishes on wooden tray that has been upcycled with a candle holder and Miss Mustard Seed Milk Paint in Ironstone

The upcycled wooden tray could be used in the bathroom too.

Cotton balls, Q-tips and handmade soaps would all look nice in this pedestal tray

close up shot of upcycled wooden tray with fruit inside and showing chippy milk paint finish

your ideas!

Share some of your ideas for this makeover in the comments below! I would love to hear how you would use it in your home!

join our journey

We would love you to join our journey over on Instagram and Facebook! You can also find more inspiration on our Pinterest page! We’re always pinning fresh ideas!

Are you looking for ideas to reinvent? Sign up below and I will send you a list filled with inspiration! Plus, you’ll get the free tutorials sent straight to your inbox!

before and after Pinterest graphic showing upcycled wooden tray makeover

Similar Posts


  1. Just watched your YouTube vid with Anna, then jumped over to your site for the detailed information you spoke about in the video. What a cute idea! I see these items at a local auction I go to weekly and now I’m inspired to do this project! Thanks for the great and entertaining vid as well as the details on your site❤️

      1. Yes! It’s so fun to turn something ordinary into something useful and interesting to boot!

  2. Oh wow, this makes me want to get to the thrift store something awful! I love how this turned out. Super cute. We are featuring it at Farmhouse Friday LP this week. Thank you for linking up. Hope you can link up again soon!

  3. This is super creative and so darling, Cindy! I’m going to be on the hunt for pieces I can use to recreate the look. Beautiful job!

  4. This is so clever and super cute! I’d love for you to share it at the Sundays on Silverado link party, too!
    Niky @ The House on Silverado

    1. Thanks Niky! Isn’t it a fun and easy project?? I will hop over to your blog and check out the link party!

  5. Cindy,
    I love this idea. It looks so great with your other vintage items. I’d like to share a link to your post on my Sunday, Dirt Road Adventures. I hope that’s ok. Thanks for your inspiration. I pinned as a reminder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *